What cash buyers have been doing here in the last 12 months.
Data last updated
In Sharon Twp (43214), investors own about 22 tracked properties across 4 active buyers, with a median investor purchase price near $60,000. 1 were acquired in the last 12 months.
95.2% of tracked activity in 43214 is value-add / rehab. That favors sellers bringing renovation projects: the capital here is set up to take on work, not to avoid it.
Secondary strategies round it out: buy & hold (4.8%) and new construction (0.0%). Pitching to them is how a non-standard property still finds a cash buyer in 43214.
Investors have not bought new builds here in the past three months; the action is in existing homes. 20 tracked investments involve construction — a signal of buyers willing to build or rebuild. Value-add work (95.2%) far outweighs new construction (0.0%), so fixer inventory has a ready audience.
Ranch is the property type investors buy most in 43214. The typical investor-held building is about 1,026 square feet, compact by most buyers' standards; 2 bd / 1 ba is the layout you will see on the most deal sheets. Dividing the median price by the median size gives a rough $58 per square foot — a quick sanity check before you trust a comp.
Typical construction year on investor-owned property is 1949. With 95.2% built before 1980, expect pre-1978 disclosure obligations and aging mechanicals on most of what trades.
43214 has 4 active cash buyers holding roughly 22 properties. Averaging below 0.3 purchases per buyer last year, this is a wide, shallow pool — a numbers game where reach beats depth.
The median investor purchase lands near $60,000. The gap between that median and the $79,000 average is the story here — a few outsized trades, with the real volume well underneath them.
Roughly 4.5% of what investors hold here changed hands in the past year. That is slow turnover — long holds, few sellers, and a premium on finding the owner who is finally ready.
Set against the other ZIP codes in Franklin County, ZIP 43214 comes in 39th out of 40 for investor buying (1 purchases in 12 months). A typical ZIP code in the county logs 76, so this is one of the quieter corners — less competition, smaller buyer pool. That is under 1% of every investor purchase in the county.
Expect older homes here — median construction in 1949, 25 years earlier than the 1974 typical across the county. Pre-1980 stock makes up 95% here against 56% in a typical ZIP code, so rehab budgets should run heavier than county comps suggest.
If you like ZIP 43214, look at 43125 in Madison Twp next — similar volume (5 deals) and similar pricing ($72,000). The county leader on volume is 43224 in Columbus (590 purchases), a useful benchmark for how deep demand can run here.
Entry costs are lower here — $60,000 at the median versus $106,000 across Franklin County, about 43% less. Its nearest neighbors on the price ladder are 43205 in Columbus just below at $52,000 and 43213 in Whitehall just above at $69,000.
| ZIP code | Active buyers | Purchases (12 mo) | Year over year | Median price | Median year built |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 43224 (Columbus) | 92 | 590 | +427% | $72,000 | 1968 |
| 43004 (Columbus) | 19 | 588 | -6% | $144,000 | 1999 |
| 43068 (Columbus) | 34 | 368 | +895% | $105,000 | 1998 |
| 43209 (Columbus) | 39 | 274 | +1042% | $81,000 | 1966 |
| 43119 (Prairie Twp) | 24 | 197 | +2089% | $167,000 | 1978 |
| 43110 (Columbus) | 44 | 192 | -89% | $136,000 | 2003 |
| 43215 (Columbus) | 25 | 163 | -48% | $31,465,000 | 2015 |
| 43214 (Sharon Twp)(this page) | 4 | 1 | — | $60,000 | 1949 |
Old housing and almost no new building is the signature of a mature area. Supply is set; the only lever is condition. Old stock that is not trading much is the harder version of this market. The improvement opportunity exists on paper, but the capital to execute it is not visibly active, and an area can sit in that state for years — this is where a market genuinely needs developers or renovation money to arrive before much changes.
An owner in 43214 is not being courted. That makes a first approach more likely to be heard — and more likely to meet an expectation formed in a different market, since nothing recent has corrected it. The age of the housing shapes the motivation. Where most stock predates 1980, the owner considering a sale is often facing a repair bill they do not want to finance — a roof, a system, a code item — and an investor's cash offer is attractive precisely because it skips the renovation they would otherwise have to fund themselves.
With a median near $60,000, many purchases here are within reach of a buyer's own cash, which removes the lender from the transaction entirely. Those deals close fastest of all, and the buyer's only real constraint is how many they can manage at once. With stock moving slowly, buyers here are planning to own for a while. Carry cost becomes part of the underwriting, which favors properties that can be occupied sooner rather than gutted first.
43214 is older-stock territory, which selects for buyers comfortable with systems work — roofs, electrical, plumbing — rather than cosmetic turns. The ceiling is arithmetic. Buying at $60,000 under a 70%-of-resale rule points to an exit value around $86,000, and a buyer whose repair estimate runs higher than yours will simply move down their list.
At around 5% turnover, 43214 is quiet. The stock is owned, not traded, so expect a longer search for the buyer who is actually in the market this quarter. With only 4 active buyers, relationship risk is real: lose one and you have lost a meaningful share of your exit options. Markets this thin reward depth over volume, and reward having a second area in rotation.
4 buyers and only 1 purchases in a year means most buyers here are waiting rather than closing. Controlling a contract is the scarce position; placing one is not the hard part.
The honest risk in 43214 is concentration. With 4 active buyers, a market this narrow can effectively close if two or three of them stop buying — and nothing in the data would warn you in advance, because the figures describe what already happened. Anyone building a pipeline here should keep a second market warm. One structural caveat applies to all of it: these figures come from recorded transactions, which lag the market by weeks to months depending on how quickly the county records. A market that turned last month looks unchanged here, so treat the numbers as a reliable description of the recent past rather than a live feed.
For a wholesaler, the sweet spot is roughly $51,000 to $69,000; outside it you are pitching to a thinner slice of buyers. With buying this spread out, plan to put a deal in front of dozens of the 4 buyers rather than a handful.
Agreedment holds 22 buyer contact records for 43214, about 5.5 per active buyer, so most names on the list come with a way to reach them.
Begin with a shortlist near 3 names, selected on what they have bought rather than on how reachable they are. Working 43214 from a focused list is how you develop a feel for local pricing without burning the relationships you will need later. Next, choose where. Investor activity clusters in 43235, 43214 and 43229, and treating 43214 as uniform is the most common way to waste a marketing budget. Turnover is the ranking that matters; count just tells you which ZIP is largest. Finally, budget time. Slow turnover means a longer search for the buyer who is actually active this quarter, and an assignment priced for a quick flip will erode while you look.

Counts and prices here are drawn from recorded investor purchases in this ZIP code and refresh with new records. They are a record of past activity, not a forecast or investment advice.