What cash buyers have been doing here in the last 12 months.
Data last updated
In Upper Arlington (43221), investors own about 560 tracked properties across 24 active buyers, with a median investor purchase price near $150,000. 26 were acquired in the last 12 months.
Acquisition pace is accelerating: 26 properties bought in the last 12 months against roughly 19 the year before, up about 37%. Competition for contracts is rising, and buyers who were quiet a year ago are active again.
24 cash buyers are active in 43221, and between them they hold about 560 properties. At under 1.1 deals per buyer in 12 months, no small group controls this market; expect to work a longer list for the same volume.
Typical deal size in 43221 sits around $150,000. An average of $194,000 against that median means a handful of large purchases are skewing the mean. Use the median when you price, or you will aim high and lose the middle of the market.
4.6% of the investor-owned stock in 43221 was bought within the last 12 months. Holdings here are sticky, which makes off-market outreach to long-time owners more valuable than waiting for listings.
The median investor-owned home was built around 1953. With 96.2% built before 1980, expect pre-1978 disclosure obligations and aging mechanicals on most of what trades.
Investors have not bought new builds here in the past three months; the action is in existing homes. 511 tracked investments involve construction — a signal of buyers willing to build or rebuild. Value-add work (96.2%) far outweighs new construction (0.8%), so fixer inventory has a ready audience.
Most capital here runs value-add / rehab — 96.2% of tracked activity. Rehab-oriented money rewards deals other buyers pass on, so condition matters less here than margin.
Secondary strategies round it out: buy & hold (3.0%) and new construction (0.8%). Pitching to them is how a non-standard property still finds a cash buyer in 43221.
The typical investor-held building is about 1,759 square feet, mid-sized by most buyers' standards, and the layout that comes up most is 3 bd / 2 ba. Dividing the median price by the median size gives a rough $85 per square foot — a quick sanity check before you trust a comp.
Set against the other ZIP codes in Franklin County, ZIP 43221 comes in 31st out of 40 for investor buying (26 purchases in 12 months). A typical ZIP code in the county logs 84, so this is one of the quieter corners — less competition, smaller buyer pool. It accounts for under 1% of all investor purchases recorded in Franklin County.
Expect older homes here — median construction in 1953, 21 years earlier than the 1974 typical across the county. Pre-1980 stock makes up 96% here against 56% in a typical ZIP code, so rehab budgets should run heavier than county comps suggest. Buildings are larger too, around 1,759 sq ft versus 1,075 for the county's typical ZIP code.
43230 in Gahanna behaves most like ZIP 43221 on volume and price (28 purchases, $130,000 median), which makes it the natural second market to work. For scale, the county's busiest ZIP code is 43224 in Columbus, at 590 investor purchases.
ZIP 43221 is one of the pricier stops in the county, with a median purchase of $150,000 against $105,000 for its typical neighbor — 43% higher. Its nearest neighbors on the price ladder are 43004 in Columbus just below at $144,000 and 43085 in Columbus just above at $154,000.
Capital is shifting into ZIP 43221. Year over year it is up 37%, while Franklin County is down 55% — 92 points better.
| ZIP code | Active buyers | Purchases (12 mo) | Year over year | Median price | Median year built |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 43224 (Columbus) | 92 | 590 | +427% | $72,000 | 1968 |
| 43004 (Columbus) | 19 | 588 | -6% | $144,000 | 1999 |
| 43068 (Columbus) | 34 | 368 | +895% | $105,000 | 1998 |
| 43209 (Columbus) | 39 | 274 | +1042% | $81,000 | 1966 |
| 43119 (Prairie Twp) | 24 | 197 | +2089% | $167,000 | 1978 |
| 43110 (Columbus) | 44 | 192 | -89% | $136,000 | 2003 |
| 43215 (Columbus) | 25 | 163 | -48% | $31,465,000 | 2015 |
| 43221 (Upper Arlington)(this page) | 24 | 26 | +37% | $150,000 | 1953 |
43221 reads as a market under construction. New building carries real weight in the investor record and the housing is young — the profile of an area where supply is still being added rather than traded. For a wholesaler that has a specific consequence: you are competing with new inventory. A buyer who can purchase something built this year, with no deferred maintenance, discounts an older property more steeply than the comps alone would suggest. Behind the share figure sit 511 construction-linked investments — money actually deployed into building, not merely interest expressed.
At roughly 1.1 deals per buyer, this is a balanced market. Buyers are active enough to be real and not so active that they can afford to be dismissive.
An owner in 43221 is not being courted. That makes a first approach more likely to be heard — and more likely to meet an expectation formed in a different market, since nothing recent has corrected it. Old stock creates its own sellers. In housing this age, deferred maintenance eventually forces a decision, and selling as-is to cash is frequently the cheaper path for an owner who cannot or will not take on the work.
At $150,000, financing is often beside the point — the buyer simply writes the check. The practical consequence is speed, and a competitive field where availability matters more than terms. With stock moving slowly, buyers here are planning to own for a while. Carry cost becomes part of the underwriting, which favors properties that can be occupied sooner rather than gutted first.
Spread across the year, 26 purchases works out to roughly 2 a month in 43221. That cadence is the useful planning number: it tells you how many opportunities realistically exist in a given month, and therefore how much of your pipeline this one market can carry. Worth noting what is absent: despite 511 construction-linked investments on record, none closed in the last 90 days. A pause that clean in a market with this much building history suggests builders are waiting on something — financing costs, approvals, or demand they are no longer sure of.
The operator who thrives in 43221 prices for deferred maintenance, because the housing here is old enough that most of it carries some. The ceiling is arithmetic. Buying at $150,000 under a 70%-of-resale rule points to an exit value around $214,000, and a buyer whose repair estimate runs higher than yours will simply move down their list.
At around 5% turnover, 43221 is quiet. The stock is owned, not traded, so expect a longer search for the buyer who is actually in the market this quarter. At 24 buyers, this is a market you can know personally. That is an advantage — a wholesaler who understands each buyer's pattern outperforms a bigger list worked blindly.
These numbers describe completed, recorded transactions. That makes them solid ground for strategy and a poor instrument for timing, since the most recent weeks are always underrepresented.
For a wholesaler, the sweet spot is roughly $128,000 to $173,000; outside it you are pitching to a thinner slice of buyers. With buying this spread out, plan to put a deal in front of dozens of the 24 buyers rather than a handful. Rising volume rewards speed — have the deal sheet, photos and access ready before you send it.
Begin with a shortlist near 4 names, selected on what they have bought rather than on how reachable they are. Working 43221 from a focused list is how you develop a feel for local pricing without burning the relationships you will need later. Then narrow geographically. 43221, 43220 and 43212 account for an outsized share of the buying here, and effort spent outside them competes for the same hours at a lower hit rate. The right ranking is purchases divided by investor-held stock, not purchases alone. Finally, budget time. Slow turnover means a longer search for the buyer who is actually active this quarter, and an assignment priced for a quick flip will erode while you look.

Counts and prices here are drawn from recorded investor purchases in this ZIP code and refresh with new records. They are a record of past activity, not a forecast or investment advice.