What cash buyers have been doing here in the last 12 months.
Data last updated
In Upper Arlington, investors own about 1,172 tracked properties across 34 active buyers, with a median investor purchase price near $156,000. 42 were acquired in the last 12 months.
Acquisition pace is accelerating: 42 properties bought in the last 12 months against roughly 25 the year before, up about 68%. Competition for contracts is rising, and buyers who were quiet a year ago are active again.
3.6% of the investor-owned stock in Upper Arlington was bought within the last 12 months. That is slow turnover — long holds, few sellers, and a premium on finding the owner who is finally ready.
Across Upper Arlington, 34 active buyers account for approximately 1,172 investor-held properties. Each averaged under 1.2 purchases over the last 12 months, so the pool is broad rather than concentrated: more names to work, with less riding on any single relationship.
The median investor purchase lands near $156,000. The gap between that median and the $197,000 average is the story here — a few outsized trades, with the real volume well underneath them.
Upper Arlington sits 9th among 36 Franklin County communities by 12-month investor purchases — 42 of them. That is about 3.2× the 13 logged by a typical community in the county. Put another way, under 1% of the county's investor deals in the last year happened here.
Upper Arlington is outrunning its county. Purchases here are up 68% on the year while Franklin County overall is down 55%, so investors are rotating toward it.
Expect older homes here — median construction in 1961, 9 years earlier than the 1970 typical across the county. Buildings are larger too, around 1,684 sq ft versus 1,404 for the county's typical community.
Reynoldsburg behaves most like Upper Arlington on volume and price (45 purchases, $125,000 median), which makes it the natural second market to work. For scale, the county's busiest community is Columbus, at 7,712 investor purchases.
Investors pay more in Upper Arlington: a $156,000 median is about 30% above the $120,000 typical across Franklin County. A step down is Gahanna at $137,000; a step up, Canal Winchester at $168,000.
| Community | Active buyers | Purchases (12 mo) | Year over year | Median price | Median year built |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Columbus | 609 | 7,712 | -56% | $132,000 | 1986 |
| Hilliard | 52 | 259 | -62% | $172,000 | 2014 |
| Prairie Twp | 60 | 244 | +639% | $125,000 | 1962 |
| Grove City | 72 | 117 | -79% | $176,000 | 1988 |
| New Albany | 22 | 93 | +27% | $350,000 | 1994 |
| Bexley | 18 | 68 | +300% | $128,000 | 1941 |
| Reynoldsburg | 44 | 45 | -69% | $125,000 | 1971 |
| Upper Arlington(this page) | 34 | 42 | +68% | $156,000 | 1961 |
The signature here is expansion. A meaningful share of investor activity is new construction and the stock skews recent, which is what a growing footprint looks like in the data. Builders commit before the growth is visible, so this pattern tends to lead rather than follow. For a wholesaler that has a specific consequence: you are competing with new inventory. A buyer who can purchase something built this year, with no deferred maintenance, discounts an older property more steeply than the comps alone would suggest. Behind the share figure sit 813 construction-linked investments — money actually deployed into building, not merely interest expressed.
From the owner's side, Upper Arlington is quiet. Many owners here have not been approached recently and have no current sense of what their property would fetch, which cuts both ways: less fatigue to overcome, and a price expectation anchored to whatever they last heard, possibly years ago. With most houses built before 1980, the common seller story here is a maintenance obligation arriving at a bad time. That owner is not optimizing for top dollar; they are optimizing for certainty and speed.
Deals near $156,000 are the natural range for bridge and hard-money lenders. That funding structure rewards certainty, so a clean file often beats a cheaper competing contract. Low turnover suggests longer holds, whether by intent or because exits are slow here. Either way the buyer is accepting carry, and a property that generates income during the hold is worth materially more to them than one that sits empty.
Spread across the year, 42 purchases works out to roughly 4 a month in Upper Arlington. That cadence is the useful planning number: it tells you how many opportunities realistically exist in a given month, and therefore how much of your pipeline this one market can carry. Construction has gone quiet. 813 such investments sit in the record and zero landed in the last quarter, which is a real change in behavior rather than noise, and usually means capital is holding for a reason.
Buyers active in Upper Arlington are underwriting age: the stock is old, and the rehab budgets reflect it. That model has a ceiling you can calculate. A purchase at $156,000 implies an after-repair value near $223,000 once the usual 70%-less-repairs discipline is applied — which is why a contract priced on hope rather than on resale gets a fast no.
A wholesaler should go into Upper Arlington with clear eyes: only about 4% of investor-held property traded in the last year, which is bottom-quartile turnover. There is investor money here, but it is sitting rather than cycling. At 34 buyers, this is a market you can know personally. That is an advantage — a wholesaler who understands each buyer's pattern outperforms a bigger list worked blindly.
At roughly 1.2 deals per buyer, this is a balanced market. Buyers are active enough to be real and not so active that they can afford to be dismissive.
For a wholesaler, the sweet spot is roughly $133,000 to $179,000; outside it you are pitching to a thinner slice of buyers. With buying this spread out, plan to put a deal in front of dozens of the 34 buyers rather than a handful. Rising volume rewards speed — have the deal sheet, photos and access ready before you send it.
Deal flow clusters in 43221, 43220 and 43212. Those ZIPs lead Upper Arlington on investor purchases, so they repay attention first before working outward through the rest of the city.
One structural caveat applies to all of it: these figures come from recorded transactions, which lag the market by weeks to months depending on how quickly the county records. A market that turned last month looks unchanged here, so treat the numbers as a reliable description of the recent past rather than a live feed.
Begin with a shortlist near 6 names, selected on what they have bought rather than on how reachable they are. Working Upper Arlington from a focused list is how you develop a feel for local pricing without burning the relationships you will need later. Then narrow geographically. 43221, 43220 and 43212 account for an outsized share of the buying here, and effort spent outside them competes for the same hours at a lower hit rate. The right ranking is purchases divided by investor-held stock, not purchases alone. Finally, budget time. Slow turnover means a longer search for the buyer who is actually active this quarter, and an assignment priced for a quick flip will erode while you look.

The dominant play is value-add / rehab, at 71.9% of tracked activity. Buyers geared for renovation will look at stock that would not trade in a new-construction market.
Square footage centers on 1,684, so think mid-sized homes; 3 bd / 2 ba is the layout you will see on the most deal sheets. Dividing the median price by the median size gives a rough $93 per square foot — a quick sanity check before you trust a comp.
Investor-held stock here dates to a median of 1961. 71.9% of the stock is pre-1980 — budget for older wiring, plumbing and the paperwork that comes with it.
Investors have not bought new builds here in the past three months; the action is in existing homes. Construction-linked investments number 813, which tells you some capital here is patient enough to put up new square footage. Value-add work (71.9%) far outweighs new construction (0.4%), so fixer inventory has a ready audience.
All figures above reflect recorded transactions in this city and update as records are processed. Past activity only — nothing here is a forecast or investment advice.