Investor purchase activity, drawn from the last 12 months of records.
Data last updated
In Hilliard, investors own about 1,450 tracked properties across 52 active buyers, with a median investor purchase price near $172,000. 259 were acquired in the last 12 months.
Volume fell to 259 investor purchases over the last 12 months from about 681, down some 62%. Negotiating leverage has shifted toward whoever is still buying.
Half of investor purchases here close below $172,000. Because the average runs to $434,000, this market has two populations: a broad base near the median and a thin band of much larger deals.
Roughly 17.9% of what investors hold here changed hands in the past year. At that pace the whole portfolio would roll over in about 6 years — a market that trades often, with new owners entering all the time.
Hilliard has 52 active cash buyers holding roughly 1,450 properties. At roughly 5.0 purchases each over the past year, this is a concentrated pool: a handful of operators are doing the bulk of the buying, so relationships matter more than list size.
No new-construction purchases by investors were recorded in the last 90 days, so this is a resale market. Across the records, 186 investments are tied to construction or major building work. With 14.6% of activity in value-add against 0.5% in new builds, renovation is the main game.
The dominant play is buy & hold, at 84.9% of tracked activity. Buy-and-hold capital prices for yield rather than resale margin, so rent support matters more to these buyers than after-repair comps.
When cash buyers close in Hilliard, the asset is usually a condominium unit. Square footage centers on 1,216, so think mid-sized homes, most often configured as 2 bd / 2 ba. That puts the market at roughly $141 a square foot on medians alone, a handy first filter when a seller's number looks off.
Typical construction year on investor-owned property is 2014. Only about 14.6% predates 1980, so the stock skews newer and rehab scopes tend to be lighter.
Within Franklin County, Hilliard ranks 2nd of 36 communities on investor purchases, with 259 over the last year. That is about 19.9× the 13 logged by a typical community in the county. That is 2.8% of every investor purchase in the county.
Hilliard skews newer, with a 2014 median build year — 46 years later than most of Franklin County. Only 15% of the stock predates 1980, well under the 72% typical nearby, which keeps renovation surprises down. Buildings are smaller than the county norm — about 1,216 sq ft against 1,419.
Prairie Twp behaves most like Hilliard on volume and price (244 purchases, $125,000 median), which makes it the natural second market to work. For scale, the county's busiest community is Columbus, at 7,712 investor purchases.
Investors pay more in Hilliard: a $172,000 median is about 43% above the $120,000 typical across Franklin County. Its nearest neighbors on the price ladder are Perry Twp just below at $169,000 and Grove City just above at $176,000.
While Franklin County is down 55% year over year, Hilliard is down 62%. Falling behind the county can mean softer competition for whoever is still buying here.
| Community | Active buyers | Purchases (12 mo) | Year over year | Median price | Median year built |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Columbus | 609 | 7,712 | -56% | $132,000 | 1986 |
| Hilliard(this page) | 52 | 259 | -62% | $172,000 | 2014 |
| Prairie Twp | 60 | 244 | +639% | $125,000 | 1962 |
| Grove City | 72 | 117 | -79% | $176,000 | 1988 |
| New Albany | 22 | 93 | +27% | $350,000 | 1994 |
| Bexley | 18 | 68 | +300% | $128,000 | 1941 |
| Reynoldsburg | 44 | 45 | -69% | $125,000 | 1971 |
| Westerville | 39 | 45 | -86% | $121,000 | 1981 |
Hilliard reads as a market under construction. New building carries real weight in the investor record and the housing is young — the profile of an area where supply is still being added rather than traded. The practical effect is on condition. In a market where buyers can choose new, a property needing work competes on price alone, and the gap is wider than a comp sheet implies. Behind the share figure sit 186 construction-linked investments — money actually deployed into building, not merely interest expressed.
Spread across the year, 259 purchases works out to roughly 22 a month in Hilliard. That cadence is the useful planning number: it tells you how many opportunities realistically exist in a given month, and therefore how much of your pipeline this one market can carry. Worth noting what is absent: despite 186 construction-linked investments on record, none closed in the last 90 days. A pause that clean in a market with this much building history suggests builders are waiting on something — financing costs, approvals, or demand they are no longer sure of.
Capital in Hilliard is patient — the low renovation share says buyers want property that performs as-is. A hold buyer at $172,000 is solving for yield, so the question they ask is not what the house is worth but what it rents for and how reliably. A credible rent figure moves a deal here further than a renovation scope ever will.
Hilliard turns over about 18% annually, around the middle of the range. Results here will track the quality of your buyer list more than the heat of the market. At 52 buyers, this is a market you can know personally. That is an advantage — a wholesaler who understands each buyer's pattern outperforms a bigger list worked blindly.
Owners in Hilliard see periodic investor interest. That is a useful middle: the concept is familiar, the fatigue has not set in.
A median around $172,000 sits in the band where hard money dominates: short-term, asset-backed, priced for speed rather than cost. A buyer on a hard-money clock has a powerful reason to close fast, which is leverage for a wholesaler who can deliver access and title quickly. The exit here is mostly that there is no exit: hold capital intends to keep the asset, so the relevant question is not resale timing but whether the property performs for years. That makes these buyers slower to decide and far stickier once they do.
Price dispersion is wide enough to mislead. Because the mean sits far above the median, an average-based comp will overstate what this market pays, and a contract priced that way sits unsold while the wholesaler blames the buyers. One structural caveat applies to all of it: these figures come from recorded transactions, which lag the market by weeks to months depending on how quickly the county records. A market that turned last month looks unchanged here, so treat the numbers as a reliable description of the recent past rather than a live feed.
For a wholesaler, the sweet spot is roughly $146,000 to $198,000; outside it you are pitching to a thinner slice of buyers. Start with the 6 most active buyers; at this level of repeat buying they will see most of what is worth seeing. With volume falling, give buyers more room: a realistic assignment fee and a longer close will move more contracts.
Activity is not spread evenly. ZIPs 43016, 43026 and 43221 are absorbing the most investor purchases in Hilliard, and they are the fastest place to start a buyer list before working outward through the rest of the city.
A sensible entry into Hilliard starts with about 8 buyers — the ones whose purchase history matches your likely inventory — rather than with the full pool. Depth first, breadth later: you learn what this market pays by watching a handful of buyers closely. Next, choose where. Investor activity clusters in 43016, 43026 and 43221, and treating Hilliard as uniform is the most common way to waste a marketing budget. Turnover is the ranking that matters; count just tells you which ZIP is largest. Third, plan for a longer cycle. With stock moving slowly, expect weeks rather than days between a contract and a committed buyer, and price the assignment so that patience is affordable. A fee that only works on a fast close will not survive this market.

Counts and prices here are drawn from recorded investor purchases in this city and refresh with new records. They are a record of past activity, not a forecast or investment advice.