What cash buyers have been doing here in the last 12 months.
Data last updated
In Reynoldsburg, investors own about 684 tracked properties across 44 active buyers, with a median investor purchase price near $125,000. 45 were acquired in the last 12 months.
Volume fell to 45 investor purchases over the last 12 months from about 146, down some 69%. Negotiating leverage has shifted toward whoever is still buying.
The median investor purchase lands near $125,000. The gap between that median and the $1,345,000 average is the story here — a few outsized trades, with the real volume well underneath them.
Of everything investors own in Reynoldsburg, 6.6% is a purchase from the last year. Owners here sit on property; at this pace the stock would take 15+ years to turn over, so new supply is scarce.
44 cash buyers are active in Reynoldsburg, and between them they hold about 684 properties. Each averaged under 1.0 purchases over the last 12 months, so the pool is broad rather than concentrated: more names to work, with less riding on any single relationship.
Within Franklin County, Reynoldsburg ranks 7th of 36 communities on investor purchases, with 45 over the last year. That is about 3.5× the 13 logged by a typical community in the county. Put another way, under 1% of the county's investor deals in the last year happened here.
Momentum runs against Reynoldsburg: purchases are down 69% year over year, 14 points behind the county (down 55%).
The stock here is about as old as the county's — median 1971 versus 1968.
If you like Reynoldsburg, look at Westerville next — similar volume (45 deals) and similar pricing ($121,000). The county leader on volume is Columbus (7,712 purchases), a useful benchmark for how deep demand can run here.
At a $125,000 median, Reynoldsburg prices almost exactly in line with the rest of Franklin County ($120,000). On price it sits between Westerville ($121,000) and Bexley ($128,000).
| Community | Active buyers | Purchases (12 mo) | Year over year | Median price | Median year built |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Columbus | 609 | 7,712 | -56% | $132,000 | 1986 |
| Hilliard | 52 | 259 | -62% | $172,000 | 2014 |
| Prairie Twp | 60 | 244 | +639% | $125,000 | 1962 |
| Grove City | 72 | 117 | -79% | $176,000 | 1988 |
| New Albany | 22 | 93 | +27% | $350,000 | 1994 |
| Bexley | 18 | 68 | +300% | $128,000 | 1941 |
| Reynoldsburg(this page) | 44 | 45 | -69% | $125,000 | 1971 |
| Westerville | 39 | 45 | -86% | $121,000 | 1981 |
Nothing in the age or construction data marks Reynoldsburg as rising or fading. In a market like this the edge comes from block-level familiarity rather than from timing a trend.
In a market this still, the owner's frame of reference is dated. Expect genuine interest in the conversation alongside a number rooted in an older market. Old stock creates its own sellers. In housing this age, deferred maintenance eventually forces a decision, and selling as-is to cash is frequently the cheaper path for an owner who cannot or will not take on the work.
At $125,000, financing is often beside the point — the buyer simply writes the check. The practical consequence is speed, and a competitive field where availability matters more than terms. Low turnover suggests longer holds, whether by intent or because exits are slow here. Either way the buyer is accepting carry, and a property that generates income during the hold is worth materially more to them than one that sits empty.
Spread across the year, 45 purchases works out to roughly 4 a month in Reynoldsburg. That cadence is the useful planning number: it tells you how many opportunities realistically exist in a given month, and therefore how much of your pipeline this one market can carry. Worth noting what is absent: despite 401 construction-linked investments on record, none closed in the last 90 days. A pause that clean in a market with this much building history suggests builders are waiting on something — financing costs, approvals, or demand they are no longer sure of.
Buyers active in Reynoldsburg are underwriting age: the stock is old, and the rehab budgets reflect it. That model has a ceiling you can calculate. A purchase at $125,000 implies an after-repair value near $179,000 once the usual 70%-less-repairs discipline is applied — which is why a contract priced on hope rather than on resale gets a fast no.
Reynoldsburg holds investor property that mostly is not moving — roughly 7% turnover over twelve months. That is a holding market, and holding markets place fewer contracts regardless of how many buyers appear on a list. At 44 buyers, this is a market you can know personally. That is an advantage — a wholesaler who understands each buyer's pattern outperforms a bigger list worked blindly.
At roughly 1.0 deals per buyer, this is a balanced market. Buyers are active enough to be real and not so active that they can afford to be dismissive.
If you are wholesaling in Reynoldsburg, a contract priced between $106,000 and $144,000 sits inside the band where most investor money already moves. Expect to go wide: no small group dominates, so a blast to a broad slice of the 44 buyers beats a curated shortlist. With volume falling, give buyers more room: a realistic assignment fee and a longer close will move more contracts.
Buying concentrates geographically: 43068 and 43004 take the largest share of investor purchases in Reynoldsburg, which makes them the obvious first targets before working outward through the rest of the city.
Price dispersion is wide enough to mislead. Because the mean sits far above the median, an average-based comp will overstate what this market pays, and a contract priced that way sits unsold while the wholesaler blames the buyers. One structural caveat applies to all of it: these figures come from recorded transactions, which lag the market by weeks to months depending on how quickly the county records. A market that turned last month looks unchanged here, so treat the numbers as a reliable description of the recent past rather than a live feed.
If Reynoldsburg is new to you, the first move is narrowing rather than broadening: build a shortlist of roughly 7 buyers whose recorded purchases match the kind of property you can actually source, and learn those names properly before widening. A small list worked well outperforms a long one worked thinly, and the data to build it already exists in the purchase record. Second, pick your ground. Activity in Reynoldsburg concentrates rather than spreading evenly — 43068 and 43004 carry a disproportionate share — so farming the whole area equally wastes effort on blocks where investors are barely transacting. Rank by turnover rather than raw count, because raw count mostly measures how big a ZIP is. Third, plan for a longer cycle. With stock moving slowly, expect weeks rather than days between a contract and a committed buyer, and price the assignment so that patience is affordable. A fee that only works on a fast close will not survive this market.

The median investor-owned home was built around 1971. 71.5% of the stock is pre-1980 — budget for older wiring, plumbing and the paperwork that comes with it.
No new-construction purchases by investors were recorded in the last 90 days, so this is a resale market. Across the records, 401 investments are tied to construction or major building work. With 71.5% of activity in value-add against 2.0% in new builds, renovation is the main game.
The dominant play is value-add / rehab, at 71.5% of tracked activity. That favors sellers bringing renovation projects: the capital here is set up to take on work, not to avoid it.
The rest of the mix is buy & hold (26.5%) and new construction (2.0%). Those secondary buyers are worth a line on your list — they tend to see less competition for the same contract.
Median building size sits near 1,404 sq ft — mid-sized housing, and the layout that comes up most is 3 bd / 2 ba. Dividing the median price by the median size gives a rough $89 per square foot — a quick sanity check before you trust a comp.
All figures above reflect recorded transactions in this city and update as records are processed. Past activity only — nothing here is a forecast or investment advice.