What cash buyers have been doing here in the last 12 months.
Data last updated
In Centerville (45440), investors own about 21 tracked properties across 7 active buyers, with a median investor purchase price near $110,000. 1 were acquired in the last 12 months.
The trend is downward: 1 purchases against 2 the prior year, a decline of about 50%. Deals take longer to place here, and sellers who price for last year's market will sit.
Investors here buy at a median of $110,000. The average of $156,000 sits well above it, so a tail of higher-priced deals is pulling the mean up — most activity happens below the average, and pricing off the median is the safer read.
Of everything investors own in 45440, 4.8% is a purchase from the last year. That is slow turnover — long holds, few sellers, and a premium on finding the owner who is finally ready.
7 cash buyers are active in 45440, and between them they hold about 21 properties. Each averaged under 0.1 purchases over the last 12 months, so the pool is broad rather than concentrated: more names to work, with less riding on any single relationship.
ZIP 45440 sits 32nd among 34 Montgomery County ZIP codes by 12-month investor purchases — 1 of them. Against a county-typical 25, that is a lighter market, which can mean less bidding pressure on each contract. That is under 1% of every investor purchase in the county.
Momentum runs against ZIP 45440: purchases are down 50% year over year, 29 points behind the county (down 21%).
The homes are newer than the county norm: median 1973 against 1956 in the typical ZIP code, 17 years younger. Only 57% of the stock predates 1980, well under the 89% typical nearby, which keeps renovation surprises down. Buildings are larger too, around 1,564 sq ft versus 1,326 for the county's typical ZIP code.
45325 in Farmersville behaves most like ZIP 45440 on volume and price (1 purchases, $260,000 median), which makes it the natural second market to work. For scale, the county's busiest ZIP code is 45417 in Dayton, at 229 investor purchases.
ZIP 45440 is a value market by county standards: its $110,000 median runs 31% below the $159,000 typical of other ZIP codes. On price it sits between 45416 in Trotwood ($108,000) and 45426 in Trotwood ($111,000).
| ZIP code | Active buyers | Purchases (12 mo) | Year over year | Median price | Median year built |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 45417 (Dayton) | 160 | 229 | +3% | $50,000 | 1948 |
| 45406 (Dayton) | 123 | 179 | -14% | $84,000 | 1948 |
| 45424 (Huber Heights) | 101 | 110 | -82% | $10,131,000 | 1975 |
| 45410 (Dayton) | 115 | 96 | +19% | $78,000 | 1918 |
| 45405 (Dayton) | 114 | 93 | +9% | $68,000 | 1928 |
| 45402 (Dayton) | 77 | 89 | +68% | $77,000 | 1924 |
| 45414 (Dayton) | 92 | 80 | -19% | $65,000 | 1956 |
| 45440 (Centerville)(this page) | 7 | 1 | -50% | $110,000 | 1973 |
The trajectory here is unremarkable, and that is a finding. Mixed-age stock with moderate construction means no single thesis explains the market — local knowledge outperforms a top-down read.
45440 holds investor property that mostly is not moving — roughly 5% turnover over twelve months. That is a holding market, and holding markets place fewer contracts regardless of how many buyers appear on a list. A pool of 7 is thin enough that each buyer matters. Treat the relationships as infrastructure, and do not build a pipeline that depends on any single one of them saying yes.
There is a crowding problem worth naming: 7 active buyers against 1 purchases over twelve months means fewer than one completed deal per buyer per year. Most of these buyers did not transact recently, so a contract here meets competition on the buy side — and an assignment fee priced as though buyers are desperate will not survive contact. Because condo and townhouse stock leads here, the association is a party to every deal. A pitch that cannot answer assessment and rental-cap questions will stall regardless of price.
An owner in 45440 is not being courted. That makes a first approach more likely to be heard — and more likely to meet an expectation formed in a different market, since nothing recent has corrected it.
A basis this low means self-funded purchases are common. Expect quick decisions and little lender friction, but also buyers whose appetite is limited by attention rather than capital. With stock moving slowly, buyers here are planning to own for a while. Carry cost becomes part of the underwriting, which favors properties that can be occupied sooner rather than gutted first.
Money that works in 45440 is renovation money, underwriting to what a house becomes rather than what it is. That model has a ceiling you can calculate. A purchase at $110,000 implies an after-repair value near $157,000 once the usual 70%-less-repairs discipline is applied — which is why a contract priced on hope rather than on resale gets a fast no.
For a wholesaler, the sweet spot is roughly $94,000 to $126,000; outside it you are pitching to a thinner slice of buyers. With buying this spread out, plan to put a deal in front of dozens of the 7 buyers rather than a handful. In a cooling market, price the assignment conservatively — buyers have options and they know it.
The honest risk in 45440 is concentration. With 7 active buyers, a market this narrow can effectively close if two or three of them stop buying — and nothing in the data would warn you in advance, because the figures describe what already happened. Anyone building a pipeline here should keep a second market warm. One structural caveat applies to all of it: these figures come from recorded transactions, which lag the market by weeks to months depending on how quickly the county records. A market that turned last month looks unchanged here, so treat the numbers as a reliable description of the recent past rather than a live feed.
For outreach, there are 8 contact records tied to buyers in 45440 inside the platform — more than one per active buyer.
Begin with a shortlist near 3 names, selected on what they have bought rather than on how reachable they are. Working 45440 from a focused list is how you develop a feel for local pricing without burning the relationships you will need later. Then narrow geographically. 45459, 45458 and 45440 account for an outsized share of the buying here, and effort spent outside them competes for the same hours at a lower hit rate. The right ranking is purchases divided by investor-held stock, not purchases alone. Finally, budget time. Slow turnover means a longer search for the buyer who is actually active this quarter, and an assignment priced for a quick flip will erode while you look.

The dominant play is value-add / rehab, at 57.1% of tracked activity. Buyers geared for renovation will look at stock that would not trade in a new-construction market.
The rest of the mix is buy & hold (42.9%) and new construction (0.0%). Those secondary buyers are worth a line on your list — they tend to see less competition for the same contract.
When cash buyers close in 45440, the asset is usually a condominium unit. Square footage centers on 1,564, so think mid-sized homes. Dividing the median price by the median size gives a rough $70 per square foot — a quick sanity check before you trust a comp.
The median investor-owned home was built around 1973. With 57.1% built before 1980, expect pre-1978 disclosure obligations and aging mechanicals on most of what trades.
Investors have not bought new builds here in the past three months; the action is in existing homes. Across the records, 4 investments are tied to construction or major building work. Value-add work (57.1%) far outweighs new construction (0.0%), so fixer inventory has a ready audience.
All figures above reflect recorded transactions in this ZIP code and update as records are processed. Past activity only — nothing here is a forecast or investment advice.